Material Review Board: Definition and Benefits
A Material Review Board (MRB) is a cross-functional team that decides what to do with material or parts that do not meet specification and cannot be dispositioned by a routine rule. Typical members come from quality, engineering or design, manufacturing, and planning — and from stress, purchasing, or the customer when the part requires it. The board meets on a regular cadence, documents each deviation on a nonconformance report (NCR), and chooses a disposition: use as is, rework, repair, return to supplier, or scrap.
When the MRB gets involved
Front-line quality can often follow a standing rule: a clearly scrap hole, a simple rework that is already on a work instruction, or a return of unopened supplier material. The MRB steps in when the deviation is not covered by those rules — a dimension just outside spec that might still function, a cosmetic issue on a visible part, or a supplier defect that affects a production schedule. The material stays in a hold area until the board dispositions it. Mixing it back into good stock is the failure mode the MRB exists to prevent.
The usual dispositions
- Use as is. The part will not harm fit, function, safety, or the downstream process, and the customer or specification allows that judgment. This needs evidence, not optimism.
- Rework. Additional processing can bring the part back to the original specification. Confirm that the rework itself does not weaken the part or hide the cause.
- Repair. The part can be made usable, but not fully to the original spec. Repair usually needs a tighter engineering or customer review than rework.
- Return to supplier (or debit and replace) when the nonconformance originated upstream and the contract supports it.
- Scrap. The part cannot be used, reworked, or repaired without an unacceptable risk. Scrap should be a last resort, but delaying an obvious scrap decision only adds handling cost and confusion.
Why a good MRB helps the process, not only the part
Each NCR should record one deviation, the disposition, and enough cause information to see patterns. Then the board is not only emptying a hold cage; it is feeding prevention:
- Repeat causes show up in rework rates and can be attacked with process changes, FMEA, or a tighter control plan.
- Labor and material cost of rework become visible instead of disappearing into “just get it out.”
- On-time shipment improves when held parts are decided on a clock, not left in a mystery rack.
- You know where nonconforming material is — a basic rule of any quality system.
On Northriver’s hinge line, a weekly MRB that only scraps or ships, and never asks why hole position drifted, is a cost center. A board that ties three weeks of off-center holes to drill wear and a missing tool-life check is doing Lean Six Sigma, even if nobody calls it a project. Related measures live on basic Lean Six Sigma metrics.
Exam and interview notes
Be ready to define the MRB as a cross-functional group that dispositions nonconforming material, to name use-as-is, rework, repair, and scrap (and often return to supplier), and to distinguish rework (restore the spec) from repair (make usable by a method that does not fully restore the spec). An NCR tracks the deviation; the board should not close the loop without a record.
Frequently asked questions
Is every defect an MRB item?
No. Routine, pre-approved dispositions can be handled at the line with a standard. The board is for the cases that need judgment or that carry product or customer risk.
How is this different from a change board?
A material review board decides what to do with material that already failed a requirement. A change-control or configuration board decides whether to change the requirement or the design itself. They sometimes share people; they do not share the same job.