Business Process Quality Management
Business process quality management (BPQM) is a way of managing quality through an organization's cross-functional business processes rather than department by department. Each key process gets an owner, defined customer requirements, measures of performance and a continuous improvement cycle, so that quality is built into the process instead of inspected at the end. Six Sigma and Lean are improvement methods that BPQM uses to close the gaps it finds.
Business process quality management is a range of methods an organization uses to align all the components of the business with the requirements of its customers. The aim is to reduce waste and maximize the quality of products or services at the same time.
The Six Sigma methodology is one example of a process improvement method used to redesign processes within the organization and to establish better communication between the people who work in them. Its main goal is to identify the opportunities for defects that reduce the quality of the products or services produced, and to cut them to a minimum.
What are the core elements of business process quality management?
- Process focus. Work is viewed as end-to-end processes (order to cash, procure to pay, complaint handling) that cross departments, because most defects and delays appear at the handoffs between them.
- Process ownership. Each key process has one owner who is accountable for its results across all the departments it touches.
- Customer requirements. Quality is defined by the customer of the process, internal or external, and translated into measurable critical-to-quality (CTQ) requirements using the voice of the customer.
- Measurement. The process is measured against those requirements with a small set of KPIs and Lean Six Sigma metrics, so performance is known rather than assumed.
- Continuous improvement. Gaps are closed with structured methods such as DMAIC, PDCA and kaizen.
- Standardization and control. The improved method is written into work instructions, monitored with control charts and checked through quality audits and management review.
How does BPQM compare with TQM, BPM and Six Sigma?
| Approach | Main focus | Typical output |
|---|---|---|
| Business process quality management | Quality of key cross-functional processes, each with an owner and customer requirements | Defined, measured, owned processes that keep improving |
| Total quality management (TQM) | Organization-wide quality culture involving every employee | Quality principles, training and participation across the company |
| Business process management (BPM) | Designing, executing and often automating processes for efficiency | Process models, workflows and systems |
| Six Sigma | Reducing variation and defects with data, project by project | DMAIC projects with measured results |
| Quality management system (ISO 9001) | A documented, auditable system for consistent quality | Certified quality system (see ISO 9000) |
The approaches overlap and are often combined: a process-based quality management system provides the structure, BPQM assigns ownership and measures, and Six Sigma or Lean projects deliver the improvements.
How do you implement business process quality management?
- Select the key processes. Start with the few processes that matter most to customers and the business, not all of them at once.
- Assign a process owner with the authority to change the process across departments, and form a small team from each area it touches.
- Define the customers and their requirements. Gather the voice of the customer and turn it into CTQs with targets and specification limits.
- Map the current process with a SIPOC diagram and a detailed process map, marking handoffs, rework loops and delays.
- Measure baseline performance. Collect data on yield, defects, cycle time and cost of poor quality before changing anything.
- Prioritize and improve. Use a Pareto analysis and root cause analysis to choose the biggest gaps, then run DMAIC or PDCA projects on them.
- Standardize and control. Update procedures, add mistake-proofing where possible, and track the key measures on control charts.
- Review regularly. The owner reports process performance to management and restarts the cycle when requirements or results change.
Which metrics are used in BPQM?
- First pass yield (FPY): share of units that pass a step right the first time.
- Rolled throughput yield (RTY): FPY of every step multiplied together; the chance a unit goes through the whole process with no rework.
- DPMO: defects per million opportunities, which converts to a sigma level.
- Cycle time and on-time delivery: how long the process takes and how often it meets the promised date.
- Cost of poor quality (COPQ): what rework, errors, complaints and scrap cost, part of the wider cost of quality.
- Process capability (Cp, Cpk): how well a stable process fits within customer specifications.
Worked example: an invoicing process
The numbers below are illustrative, not real company data. A finance team names an owner for its order-to-invoice process and maps three steps: enter the order, price it, and issue the invoice. A month of data gives these first pass yields:
| Step | First pass yield |
|---|---|
| 1. Enter order | 95% |
| 2. Price order | 90% |
| 3. Issue invoice | 98% |
| Rolled throughput yield | 0.95 × 0.90 × 0.98 = 0.838 (83.8%) |
So only about 838 of every 1,000 invoices go through with no rework at any step, and roughly 162 need correcting somewhere. The team also defines five defect opportunities per invoice (customer, items, quantities, prices, terms) and finds 120 defects in 1,000 invoices: 120 ÷ (1,000 × 5) × 1,000,000 = 24,000 DPMO, about 3.5 sigma using the conventional 1.5 sigma shift.
A Pareto chart shows most defects come from pricing, so the owner runs a DMAIC project on step 2. Root cause: price lists updated in one system but not the other. After a single price source and a mistake-proofing check, step 2 reaches 97% FPY and RTY rises to 0.95 × 0.97 × 0.98 = 0.903 (90.3%). The new method goes into the work instructions, pricing errors are tracked on a control chart, and the owner moves to the next gap.
Common mistakes
- Managing each department's metrics separately while nobody owns the end-to-end result.
- Defining quality from inside the company instead of from customer requirements.
- Improving before measuring, so there is no baseline to prove the change worked.
- Treating BPQM as a one-off project and skipping the control step, which lets gains slip back.
- Trying to manage every process at once instead of the few that matter most.
Frequently asked questions
What is business process quality management?
Business process quality management is an approach that manages quality through an organization's key cross-functional processes. Each process has an owner, customer requirements, performance measures and a continuous improvement cycle, so quality is built into the process rather than inspected afterwards.
How is BPQM related to Six Sigma?
BPQM provides the structure: which processes matter, who owns them and how they are measured. Six Sigma is one of the improvement methods it uses, applying DMAIC projects and data analysis to reduce defects and variation in those processes.
What is the role of a process owner?
The process owner is accountable for the performance of a whole process across departments. The owner sets targets with the customer in mind, monitors the measures, sponsors improvement work and makes sure improved methods are standardized.
What is the difference between BPQM and TQM?
Total quality management is a company-wide philosophy that involves every employee in quality. BPQM is more specific: it applies quality management to defined business processes, each with an owner and measures. Many organizations use BPQM as a practical way to put TQM principles into action.
See also: work instructions, ISO 9000, QS-9000, quality systems, quality audits, and the seven quality tools.
More on quality systems and standards in this guide: procedures and what counts as a process.
Last updated: · Published by Lean Six Sigma Training Guide (sixsigmatrainingfree.com) · How this guide is written